Pigsaw Blog
All the pig that's fit to saw

In the red corner, the iPod Touch…

I’m currently going through the most exciting and frustrating phase of another purchase cycle: the research period. This is the time when I obsess over candidate products, do loads research and cross-referencing, create spreadsheets, and generally work myself into a tizz about something almost no-one else would give a second thought to.

This time it’s (still) about getting an iPod Touch. Possibly. But it’s just got really interesting. The facts (and fantasies) are as follows:

  • My very elderly Psion Vx is going to give out sooner or later, and I’ll need a replacement organiser. (This is actually a rubbish non-justification for splashing out on some fancy gear. But I’m ignoring that.)
  • The iPod Touch is very cool, but it’s not an organiser. In fact, it’s not even got a search facility for you to search your contacts, diary and to-do items.
  • The iPod Touch has wi-fi. That’s very cool. I’ve decided that my next organiser needs wi-fi.
  • Apple will launch their SDK and it’s only a matter of time before someone turns it into an organiser. After all, as their COO says, “it’s a platform not a product”.
  • I don’t need a phone built in. I want an organiser without a phone.
  • I seriously need to find an alternative to the iPod Touch, to convince myself that I’m making a properly balanced purchasing choice. After all, I don’t want to be caught out by that sneaky Temporal Frame Information.
  • The Palm TX does not cut the mustard. It ticks all the boxes, but it looks positively stone-age next to the Touch. I was beginning to give up…
  • But amazingly, I have just discovered a real contender: the Nokia N810. It’s a proper, tiny wi-fi PC, which runs a Mozilla browser — so all those Web 2.0 applications work — and Flash. In fact there’s a little YouTube video of it, of which a big chunk consists of watching the device play a YouTube video.
  • As Last100′s excellent review points out, it’s a proper platform. With an SDK. And loads of community-built applications.
  • Plus, it’s got a camera, a microphone, and Skype included. And proper sockets (like USB), real buttons, and an actual keyboard. Very cool.
  • Today the N810 “fails abysmally as a PDA”, but it’s got an SDK, so it’s only matter of time before that changes, surely.

So this is very, very good: I have two exciting products to choose from. And now I need to try to hold back from buying one, long enough to see how the fight develops.

No doubt I will write more about this in the coming weeks. Whatever you read here, be reassured that it will be a mere shadow of a very large, and growing, obsession.

Tags: , ,

2 Responses to In the red corner, the iPod Touch… »»


Comments

  1. Comment by Dave Cross | 2008/03/04 at 13:12:08

    I bought a Nokia N800 just before the N810 was launched.

    It’s true that the N8x0 products aren’t PDAs, but that’s not what they’re marketed as. Nokia calls them “internet tablets”. Which means that they’re intended as always-on internet-connected devices. Of course, in the UK we don’t (yet) have as much free wireless as the US but Nokia has done deals with a couple of wi-fi providers that give you access for a monthly fee. Alternatively you can use bluetooth to connect via your phone.

    But anyway, the main point is that you don’t need the Nokia N8x0 to be a PDA as you can “always” access your PDA-type data on the web sites where you have outsourced it (Google Calendar, Gmail, etc). That’s the theory. Not yet 100% convinced that it works in reality.

  2. Nik
    Comment by Nik | 2008/03/05 at 10:06:01

    …you can “always” access your PDA-type data on the web sites where you have outsourced it (Google Calendar, Gmail, etc). That’s the theory.

    Yes, indeed. And that’s the theory that the iPhone officially operates on: why would anyone want to develop an app for it when you can do everything through Safari? And now they’re releasing (still releasing…) an SDK.


Leave a Reply »»